NJ Transit trains rated the worst in the nation — yet again

For a second straight 12 months, NJ Transit trains broke down far more than any other system’s in the nation in 2019, according to Federal Transit Administration data. Buses ranked eighth worst in the nation in 2019 and seventh worst among identical sized companies, these as NYC Transit.

The studies, produced this week in the Federal Transit Administration Countrywide Transit’s Database and primarily based on numbers documented to the FTA on a yearly basis by transit companies, likely did not arrive as a shock to commuters. Ahead of the coronavirus pandemic crushed general public transit ridership in 2020, commuters regularly complained about getting caught on a system, waiting for the little engine that couldn’t operate. But NJ Transit officials say they are functioning to address issues that led to the weak rankings.

If there was a sliver of mild in the tunnel, it’s that 2019′s quantities confirmed a slight improvement more than the amount of trains that broke down in 2018. NJ Transit commuter rail saw 351 total mechanical failures above 52.5 million earnings miles that trains ran in 2019. In 2018, that variety was 375. Overall mechanical failure means a educate or bus could not comprehensive or start a journey, in accordance to the FTA.

And, New Jersey’s light rail procedure did perfectly in the rating, with the fourth most effective document in the country.

In response to the rankings, Jim Smith, an NJ transit spokesman, said mechanical trustworthiness will proceed to enhance as NJ Transit can take supply of new buses and trains.

“Since 2018, NJ Transit has made wonderful strides to make up for the ten years of disinvestment prior to that time,” he reported. “Hundreds of new cruiser buses and extended articulated buses continue to get there, which bring improved mechanical trustworthiness, increased capacity and client amenities – and we truly expanded our bus fleet for the to start with time in a decade in 2020.”

NJ Transit purchased 25 new twin-run locomotives, and the to start with engines will be arriving in the coming weeks, Smith mentioned.

“We have 113 new multilevel rail cars on get that will swap the growing older 40-as well as-12 months-outdated Arrow fleet starting in 2023,” he stated. “They have a Suggest Length Between Failure that is ten periods that of the Arrow III automobiles.”

Commuter advocates are skeptical that the new railcars are likely to turn the tide and said better routine maintenance of the products they’ve received doesn’t appear to be to be going on.

“When you have trains soiled on the outdoors, it begs the query, ‘what else isn’t being taken treatment of?’ As considerably as I know, there is no rehab of rail cars and trucks planned,” reported Len Resto, New Jersey Association of Railroad Travellers president and Morris & Essex line rider. “They are pinning their hopes on double-decker (rail autos) that are two or far more a long time away and require to be analyzed to do the job out glitches.”

The agency continue to has a sizable fleet of 40-in addition-yr-aged Comet II one amount autos, which ended up rebuilt in the early 2000s. Inevitably, they are scheduled to be changed with multi-stages under a 2014 fleet plan.

Ryan Felmet, an independent transit advocate, blamed the position on, “poor administration and a lack of inside controls, this kind of as sidestepping interior audit recommendations,” and a deficiency of action to handle difficulties stemming from the “enormous amount of particular client complaints.”

“This all prospects to troubles down the line, which includes very poor upkeep, service challenges, every thing that impacts provider,” he reported. “The community warrants trustworthy assistance and not just public relations from NJ Transit leadership.”

The picture was better for NJ Transit bus riders. Buses experienced 8,514 full mechanical failures over a total of 73.4 million miles operate in income services in 2019. That was an enhancement about 2018′s 9,850 complete mechanical failures.

NJ Transit rated eighth worst in general for bus breakdowns and had seventh highest breakdowns out of comparable sized organizations. It rated much better than NYC Transit buses, which were sixth with 9,610 overall failures more than 86.23 million income services miles. NJ Transit buses had much less breakdowns than buses operated by organizations in Miami, Atlanta, Seattle, Los Angeles.

Chicago Transit Authority buses had been rated worst in the country with 18,765 overall failures although operating 52.8 million earnings miles in 2019. SEPTA Buses had the tenth highest number of breakdowns in 2019 with 7,606 complete failures in 41.1 million miles of revenue company.

Just one advocate reported NJ Transit’s bus enhancements are a final result of the system to substitute its 1,200 cruiser buses fleet and is replacing all articulated buses.

“NJ Transit built a amount of changes that could be credited to this development, primarily the addition of new buses and retiring aged buses,” explained Kevin Garcia, Tri-Condition Transportation Marketing campaign New Jersey bus coordinator. “In addition to enhancing on-time efficiency, these alterations also improve the expertise of individuals commuting such as minimizing overcrowding.”

The agency can make far more gains if it is able to proceed to introduce new buses, retire outdated buses, and seek the services of even a lot more new drivers, he reported. That also is dependent on funding, Garcia stated.

Light rail continued to be the very best performer, ranking fourth and fifth very best in 2019. Hudson-Bergen Light rail had 100 complete breakdowns about 2.1 million income miles in 2019. River line and Newark mild rail observed 178 overall breakdowns put together about 507,528 revenue miles in 2019. The 278 overall mechanical failure represented a slight increase from 263 in 2018.

Our journalism needs your assistance. You should subscribe currently to NJ.com.

Larry Higgs may possibly be reached at [email protected].